WhatsApp logo

Blog

Rental deposit: the landlord does not make the law

Three-month cap, account in the tenant's name, repayment: five claims about the rental deposit checked for your arrival in Geneva.

Particulier
Rental deposit: the landlord does not make the law

Why the deposit causes so much confusion

You arrive in Geneva with a B permit. Your family is viewing a four-room flat. The letting agency slips in: "To get off to a good start, we would need a guarantee." A few minutes later, the talk is of a deposit, a security payment, a bank guarantee, advance rent. Four terms, four different realities.
This confusion explains why so many tenants pay without checking. So here are six statements heard in the field, put through the filter of federal law. You will know what you are paying, where, and when you get it back.

"The landlord can demand up to six months' rent": false

For residential premises, the deposit may not exceed three months' rent. This is article 257e of the Code of Obligations (CO), available on fedlex.admin.ch. Any clause providing for more is contrary to the law.
Take an example. A Geneva four-room flat with a monthly net rent of CHF 2'400: the deposit is capped at CHF 7'200 (3 × 2'400). A landlord who demands CHF 9'600 exceeds the limit by CHF 2'400.
That leaves the question of service charges. The text of article 257e CO refers to "three months' rent", without specifying whether this means net rent or rent including service charges. I therefore cannot settle the point for you. Ask in writing on what basis the amount is calculated, and if in doubt, contact ASLOCA (asloca.ch) or the Conciliation Commission.
Net monthly rent
ValueCHF 2'400
ContextExample: 4-room flat in Geneva
Statutory cap on the deposit
ValueCHF 7'200
Context3 × CHF 2'400 (art. 257e CO)
Amount demanded by the landlord
ValueCHF 9'600
ContextAbusive demand, contrary to the law
Excess over the statutory cap
ValueCHF 2'400
ContextCHF 9'600 − CHF 7'200
On a 4-room flat at CHF 2'400, the statutory cap is CHF 7'200: any demand for CHF 9'600 exceeds the law by CHF 2'400

Key takeaway

For residential premises, the rental deposit may never exceed three months' rent: beyond CHF 7'200, the demand is contrary to the law.
Source: Art. 257e CO — fedlex.admin.ch

"The deposit is paid into the landlord's account": false

The law is clear: the landlord must lodge the cash deposit in a savings or deposit account, opened with a bank, in the tenant's name. The interest belongs to you. This is article 257e, paragraph 1, of the CO.
In practice, your letting agency gives you an account-opening form, or tells you which bank to use. You pay the funds directly into this account, never into the landlord's current account.
Check three things before signing the lease:
  • the account is indeed in your name
  • the bank gives you a certificate with the account number
  • the account is blocked, meaning no withdrawal without the agreement of both parties
Keep this certificate with your copy of the lease. It will be useful when you move out.

"A bank guarantee and a cash deposit are the same thing": false

They are two lawful solutions, but their mechanisms differ. With a cash deposit, you tie up a sum in a blocked account. With a bank guarantee, your bank undertakes to pay the landlord in the event of a dispute, and you keep your savings. In return, the bank charges annual fees and may require a pledge.
There are also surety insurance policies, often called rent guarantees without deposit. You pay an annual premium instead of blocking funds. Rates vary by insurer: compare them before choosing, and bear in mind that this premium is lost, whereas the cash deposit is returned to you with its interest.
For a family that has just financed a move, the temptation to free up cash is strong. Weigh the cost over the duration of the lease.
One point matters: the landlord may accept or refuse a type of guarantee, but cannot impose a specific provider on you.
Mechanism
Cash depositSum blocked in a savings or deposit account opened in your name
Bank guaranteeBank's undertaking to pay the landlord in the event of a dispute; pledge possible
Surety insuranceAnnual premium paid to an insurer, with no funds deposited
Impact on your liquidity
Cash depositCash tied up for the duration of the lease
Bank guaranteeSavings retained
Surety insuranceNo funds blocked
Recurring cost
Cash depositNo fees: the interest belongs to you
Bank guaranteeAnnual fees charged by the bank
Surety insuranceAnnual premium, rates vary by insurer
Repayment
Cash depositRecoverable with its interest
Bank guaranteeRelease of the undertaking (no sum to recover)
Surety insurancePremium lost, not refunded
Bank guarantee, cash deposit or insurance: only the deposit is returned to you with its interest

Key takeaway

All three solutions are lawful, but only the cash deposit is returned to you with its interest: the insurance premium is lost and the bank guarantee incurs annual fees.
Source: Art. 257e CO — fedlex.admin.ch

"The landlord keeps the deposit for as long as he likes": false

The landlord cannot hold on to your money indefinitely. Under article 257e, paragraph 3, of the CO, you may request repayment of the deposit one year after the end of the lease, if the landlord has made no claim. If he has notified claims, the bank releases the funds only with the agreement of both parties, or by court decision.
Everything therefore comes down to the moment you leave. At the move-out inspection, reread the record before signing it. Point out what falls under normal wear and tear. Note the defects recorded and the time limit for claims set for your later exchanges.
If damage is recorded, your household insurance with private liability cover often steps in. Check your contract before the move-out inspection, not after. To find out more about the move-out stages, see our guide on handing back a flat in Switzerland (https://www.asloca.ch/) and on terminating a lease and the notice period.

"In Geneva, it is the same rule as elsewhere": true for the cap

Tenancy law is federal. The cap of three months' rent and the obligation to use an account in the tenant's name therefore apply in Geneva just as in Zurich or Lausanne.
What changes is the situation on the ground. Geneva has a severe housing shortage, and there are many applications for each flat. This weighs on the balance of power at the viewing. I make no claim about the habits of Geneva letting agencies towards foreign tenants: I have no official source for that.
In the event of a dispute over the deposit, you may refer the matter to the Conciliation Commission for tenancy matters of the canton of Geneva. The procedure is free of charge for disputes concerning a residential lease and aims at an amicable agreement before any court action. Practical information is available on ge.ch, and ASLOCA can advise you beforehand.

"Without a C permit or a solid file, they can demand more": false

The cap of three months' rent does not depend on your status. B permit, L permit, cross-border commuter or Swiss citizen: the limit is identical. The landlord cannot raise the bar because you have just arrived or because your permit is not a C.
He does, however, remain free to choose his tenant. He may ask for:
  • an extract from the Debt Enforcement Office
  • proof of income, generally three times the rent
  • a guarantor, if your file is weak
These requirements concern the selection of applicants, not the amount of the deposit. If a file does not convince him, the landlord may refuse the applicant. He cannot circumvent the statutory cap in exchange for his agreement.
If you are coming with your family under family reunification, prepare these documents before the viewing. A complete file reassures and speeds up the decision.

Key takeaways

Four reflexes protect you:
  • Check that the amount does not exceed three months' rent.
  • Insist on a bank account in your name, never a transfer to the landlord's private account.
  • Keep the bank's certificate and the handover record.
  • Reread the inspection report before signing.
If in doubt, the Conciliation Commission and tenants' associations such as ASLOCA are there to answer your questions.
"This article is provided for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice; as the rules on rental deposits (art. 257e CO) may vary depending on the circumstances, please consult ASLOCA, a lawyer or the competent cantonal authority before taking any decision, relocation-genevoise.ch accepting no liability for its use."

FAQ

For residential premises, the deposit is capped at three months' rent, in accordance with article 257e of the Code of Obligations. For example, for a rent of CHF 2'400, the deposit may not exceed CHF 7'200.

Need help with your rental application?

We support families settling in Geneva, from the flat search to the signing of the lease. Let's discuss your situation.